From zero appointments to 20 closed deals
X3 Marketing came to Belkins after a full year with another lead generation vendor that hadn’t booked a single appointment. Over 14 months, the agency booked over 100 appointments with local business owners. More than 100 of them took place face to face, and 20 turned into closed deals.
- 115 appointments in 14 months
- 100+ in-person meetings with prospects
- 20 deals closed, about 1 in 5 in-person meetings
- 100% average KPI
- 17,000+ leads researched
- 6–7% reply rate, with open rates peaking at 54%
The campaign worked within tight limits: Colorado only, a handful of industries, and meetings the CEO could attend in person. That narrowed the pool of prospects, but it’s also why the close rate was high: every meeting was a face-to-face conversation with the person who would run the work.
“I wanted to attend all the meetings personally. Accordingly, we needed clients who were close to us. Belkins was open to my wishes and gave their best.”
— Justin Lynch, CEO/Founder, X3 Marketing Group
Challenges: A year of unqualified leads and lost trust
X3 Marketing had already tried outsourcing lead generation. Over a year, its previous vendor delivered unqualified leads and no booked appointments, mainly because it never understood the agency’s business or what it needed. X3 needed a steady, ongoing flow of qualified prospects, in a narrow niche and a competitive market, from a partner it could trust after that experience.
What X3 Marketing set out to fix
The agency wanted a consistent flow of qualified appointments with local businesses in its core industries, booked as in-person meetings the CEO could attend himself.
Belkins’ framework
The campaign ran on cold email, built around one idea: X3 Marketing is a local company that wants to grow other local companies.
Keeping outreach in Colorado
At X3’s request, the team targeted only Colorado-based businesses in a limited set of industries. Every email opened with that shared ground: X3 operates in Colorado and puts the emphasis on local partnerships.
Personalizing with each prospect’s own search data
Lead research went beyond contact details. For each prospect, the team checked how many of the company’s search terms ranked on pages 2–10 of Google, then used that number in the email. This made the problem concrete and specific to the prospect’s own website.
Writing proof for each industry
Prospects were segmented by industry, and each segment got its own value proposition built on X3’s results with similar companies. The team also A/B tested subject lines in each wave.
Here’s a shortened version of the first email:
Subject line A: coffee in {{City}}, {{FirstName}}?
Subject line B: About {{Company}}’s search resultsHi {{FirstName}},
Just like {{Company}}, X3 Marketing operates in Colorado and we put emphasis on local partnerships.
My research indicates that {{Website}} has {{Number of terms}} terms ranked on pages 2-10 of Google. With us you can have a first-page ranking for all relevant keywords in your niche.
{VP}
Will you be able to meet with me on Tuesday at 12 PM next week to discuss the expansion of {{Company}}’s digital presence? I could come by your office or we can grab a coffee nearby.
Best,
The {VP} line changed by industry. For roofing companies, it pointed to roofing clients that had seen a 200% increase in monthly site visits and a 35% improvement in customer actions on Google My Business. For restoration companies, it cited clients that gained 16 new clients a month, a 10X ROI, and 20X more daily leads.
Asking for a face-to-face meeting
Every email proposed a specific time and an in-person meeting, at the prospect’s office or over coffee nearby. That matched how the CEO wanted to sell and made the request concrete and easy to accept.
Supporting each meeting in real time
In-person meetings need close coordination between the prospect, the client, and the SDR. Belkins handled scheduling and communication at every step so the CEO could focus on the meetings themselves.
Challenges our team faced
A small pool of prospects
X3 wanted to keep its targeting limited to specific industries and to Colorado, and the team couldn’t persuade it to widen the scope. Instead, it put extra effort into research and qualification to keep fresh prospects coming.
A competitive market
Many agencies sell online visibility to local businesses. The value proposition had to speak precisely to each industry’s needs, which is why every segment got its own proof.
A client who didn’t trust vendors
After a year with no appointments, X3’s team was skeptical of appointment setting partners. Early on, the team focused on clear, frequent communication to address the client’s doubts and build a working relationship.
Why local, in-person outreach worked here
- Use location as the opening. A shared local base gave every email an immediate reason to reply.
- Show prospects their own problem. A count of the prospect’s own pages-2-10 rankings made the pitch specific in a single line.
- Match the meeting format to how the client sells. In-person meetings with the CEO produced a close rate of about 1 in 5.
This approach fits small agencies and service firms that sell to local businesses and can meet prospects in person. A firm selling across many regions, or one without the capacity to attend meetings, would need a remote meeting format and broader targeting.



